Participation: The Protokoll


This assignment represents a long-standing tradition in German universities, and with which I became familiar in graduate school. Its primary function is to re-visit the previous week's material not simply as a summary, but as a bridge--rather like the "minutes" or official record of the last class session. Each student will be responsible for one Protokoll during the quarter, either individually or as part of a small group, and this exercise will serve as a component in your participation assessment.

Volunteers will be solicited for the Week 2 Protokoll. During class Week 2, teams will be assigned to cover the remainder of the presentations.

 


The Protokoll exercise is worth 5 of the 40 points dedicated to providing evidence for active participation and professionalism in class. As with all participation exercises, students must be present both weeks in order to contribute; in other words, you can't simply mail it in.

Since the purpose of this exercise is to remind the class of the previous week's lesson(s), opening remarks must reiterate the major focus of the lecture. As you may have noticed, weekly topics have been given titles that include the scope of the slide lecture. This is where you begin. Taking careful notes during class should make the task relatively easy to complete. Other items must include some or all of the following (see the rubric at the end of this page for point values):

A brief one- or two- sentence statement that summarizes focus of the previous lecture/discussion, and includes the title listed on the weekly schedule.

A short (five-minute) summary of the major points covered: cultural context, time frame, technological innovations, and movements or artists/designers discussed. It helps to consider the question, "Why was this material important to our understanding of the history of art and design?"

A brief concluding statement or personal observation that provides a snapshot of your response to the topic and its coverage. If you left the classroom wondering about anything particular, include your questions here.

Finally, having read at least some of the assigned material for the current week, formulate a question or two designed to connect the two topics (last week's and this week's). These questions must be open-ended (not multiple choice or yes/no), with the potential for generating discussion. As a rule, questions that begin with "Why?" are the most appropriate--although a "How did they?" question may also be productive.

What NOT to do:

Provide an arbitrary rehash of last week's lecture with a few pictures to show you know how to insert photos into PowerPoint.

Show every slide from last week's presentation (or what seems to be every slide).

Misspell words or names on your slides, mis-pronounce them, or otherwise indicate that you have no idea of what was discussed in the previous lecture/discussion.

Use cute PowerPoint graphics or animations to convince your instructor that your presentation has merit, when in fact it does not.

If you absolutely must use a PowerPoint template, please choose a simple one in a suitable color scheme. Microsoft templates are notoriously free of thoughtful design, so the best way to show that you're not thinking is to choose something flashy or inappropriate.

home l schedule
10.07.09